Comments on: Put yourself in somebody else’s shoe! http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/ Iman yang kuat tak akan takut pada keraguan. Iman yang dangkal dan dogmatis selalu was-was pada pertanyaan dan keragu-raguan. Mon, 20 Jun 2011 12:51:59 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3 By: Ubil http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/comment-page-1/#comment-286 Ubil Thu, 03 Jul 2008 02:29:48 +0000 http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/#comment-286 Mas Ulil, are you a really a Muslim, who defending Islam or you are a man who want Destroying Islam ?? and the lingering questions is if you want to Improve your knowledge about " Real Islam literatures" for improving your knowledge about Islam, why you are taking a study at America ??? from a country who want destroying Islam ?? I am so confused about you....I suggest you take a new Religion for yourself or another religion Not Islam Mas Ulil, are you a really a Muslim, who defending Islam or you are a man who want Destroying Islam ?? and the lingering questions is if you want to Improve your knowledge about ” Real Islam literatures” for improving your knowledge about Islam, why you are taking a study at America ??? from a country who want destroying Islam ??
I am so confused about you….I suggest you take a new Religion for yourself or another religion Not Islam

]]> By: M http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/comment-page-1/#comment-258 M Fri, 27 Jun 2008 07:11:10 +0000 http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/#comment-258 Salam mas Ulil, So glad that u write blog, not just you have mengisi waktu luang and learn english, you have also enlight others. To me, reading ur articles is more about understanding you, then understanding Islam. In the way that, the values you propose, almost all of them i agree. therefore i was a bit surprised. Many Indonesians, recognize you as a horrifying figure- including me, before i started to read ur blog. We 'heard' that you and JIL promoted liberal Islam, which means moslem is not obliged to do prayers, that all religions are acceptable and so on. and i am sure still many Indonesian thought that your values fall under personal or individual level. But i was wrong. i found that instead of liberal, u r more to libertarian, instead of plural, u are more to tolerant. ur values are reasonable. It seems that i had successfully being directed to the misinterpretation of JIL. Or, JIL has also successfully being used for other Islam interpretation. Or is it you that have changed to be a bit more traditionalist while raising ur two children. i do not know. However, i'd like to sincerely ask apologize to you for misunderstood your values. Nevertheless, having been in the traditionalist line, and still have very many good friends and family in that group, i don't forget yet how it felt to be in their shoes. Many of them, do not know and do not have idea about what they are saying, what they are thinking about. They were born and live in such values. If you sincerely talking about putting ur feet on their shoes, u'll spend more energy to be patient and understand them; both the marginalized and the marginalizing people. salam M Salam mas Ulil,

So glad that u write blog, not just you have mengisi waktu luang and learn english, you have also enlight others.

To me, reading ur articles is more about understanding you, then understanding Islam. In the way that, the values you propose, almost all of them i agree. therefore i was a bit surprised.

Many Indonesians, recognize you as a horrifying figure- including me, before i started to read ur blog. We ‘heard’ that you and JIL promoted liberal Islam, which means moslem is not obliged to do prayers, that all religions are acceptable and so on. and i am sure still many Indonesian thought that your values fall under personal or individual level. But i was wrong. i found that instead of liberal, u r more to libertarian, instead of plural, u are more to tolerant. ur values are reasonable.

It seems that i had successfully being directed to the misinterpretation of JIL. Or, JIL has also successfully being used for other Islam interpretation. Or is it you that have changed to be a bit more traditionalist while raising ur two children.

i do not know. However, i’d like to sincerely ask apologize to you for misunderstood your values.

Nevertheless, having been in the traditionalist line, and still have very many good friends and family in that group, i don’t forget yet how it felt to be in their shoes. Many of them, do not know and do not have idea about what they are saying, what they are thinking about. They were born and live in such values.

If you sincerely talking about putting ur feet on their shoes, u’ll spend more energy to be patient and understand them; both the marginalized and the marginalizing people.

salam
M

]]> By: Hilman Nur Chozin http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/comment-page-1/#comment-257 Hilman Nur Chozin Fri, 27 Jun 2008 04:35:25 +0000 http://ulil.net/2008/06/27/put-yourself-in-somebody-elses-shoe/#comment-257 Mas Ulil, I almost think that you are telling everybody to steal someone elses shoes hehe.. just joking :-) It feels that I've done a friday sermont for reading your article, and waiting for iqamah for shalat :-) nice .. thanks... Mas Ulil, I almost think that you are telling everybody to steal someone elses shoes hehe.. just joking :-)

It feels that I’ve done a friday sermont for reading your article, and waiting for iqamah for shalat :-) nice ..

thanks…

]]>